Trump administration can’t transfer former death row inmates to ‘supermax’ prison right now, judge rules
WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge has temporarily blocked the Trump administration from transferring 20 inmates on reduced death sentences to the nation’s highest-security federal prison, warning that officials cannot use a “sham” process to determine where prisoners will be confined for the rest of their lives.
U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly ruled late Wednesday that the government cannot send former death row inmates to the federal “supermax” prison in Florence, Colorado, because that would likely violate their Fifth Amendment rights to due process.
He watches: Why did Biden commute the sentences of 37 people on federal death row?
Kelly cited evidence that officials from the Republican administration “made clear” to the federal Bureau of Prisons that prisoners should be sent to ADX Florence — the “administrative maximum” — for punishment over Democratic President Joe Biden. Their death sentences were commuted.
“At least for now, they will remain in prison for life for their heinous crimes as they currently remain in prison,” wrote Kelly, who was nominated to the court by President Donald Trump.
In December 2024, less than a month before Trump returned to the White House, Biden commuted the sentences of 37 of 40 people on federal death row, converting their sentences to life imprisonment.
On his first day back in office, Trump issued an executive order directing Attorney General Pam Bondi to house the 37 prisoners “in conditions consistent with the brutality of their crimes and the threats they pose.”
Twenty of the 37 inmates are plaintiffs in the lawsuit before Kelly, who issued a preliminary injunction blocking their transfer to Florence while the lawsuit is pending. All of them were imprisoned in Terre Haute, Indiana, when Biden commuted their death sentences.
Government lawyers have argued that the office has broad authority to decide which facilities prisoners should be reassigned to after their sentences are commuted.
“The classification decisions made by the Bank of Palestine fall within its exclusive jurisdiction and are intended to preserve the safety of guests, employees, and surrounding communities,” they wrote.
The judge concluded that the inmates had no meaningful opportunity to appeal their reassignment because the outcome of the review process appeared to have been predetermined.
“But the Constitution requires that when the government seeks to deprive someone of a liberty or property interest protected by the Due Process Clause — whether that person is a notorious prisoner or a law-abiding citizen — the process it provides cannot be a sham,” Kelly wrote.
The Florence prison holds some of the most notorious criminals in federal custody, including Unabomber Ted Kaczynski, Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, and Mexican drug lord Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman. The prisoners’ lawyers said the prison was “unparalleled in its harsh conditions.”
“The categorical reclassification challenged here deprived plaintiffs of the opportunity to show why they should not be sentenced to a life bereft of human contact, in a cell the size of a parking lot, where they would see nothing from the window but a strip of sky,” they wrote.
Government lawyers said other courts had held that the conditions were not objectively cruel and unusual.
“Plaintiffs have failed to show that the conditions at ADX were unusual for them,” they wrote.
